A grieving daughter was stunned after paying around £8,000 in inheritance tax on her late mum’s belongings – only to discover she had overvalued them by thousands.
Justine Fernandes, 54, was sorting through her mum Judith’s cottage following her death from cancer in January 2025 when she made the costly mistake.
She and her brother Julian, 51, were asked by solicitors to value their mum’s possessions as part of the inheritance tax process.
After going through antique furniture, clothes and jewellery, they estimated the items were worth around £20,000 – and paid roughly £8,000 in tax based on that figure.

But while probate was ongoing, Justine, a chartered architect, sought a professional valuation over fears they may have underestimated their worth.
Instead, she discovered the belongings were valued at just £1,500 to £2,500 – far less than their original estimate.
Justine said: “I was shocked. We were worried we may have underestimated mum’s items but in fact we had been too generous.
“We had already paid the inheritance tax based on what we thought her possessions were worth. By the time we found out their true sellable value it was too late.”


Treasured belongings worth far less than expected
One of Judith’s most treasured possessions was a pearl necklace which Justine had valued at hundreds of pounds but was actually worth around £80.
Justine and Julian sought a refund from HMRC after discovering the discrepancy but feared the process could take years.
She said: “Losing a loved one is extremely emotional and you don’t want to think that their possessions are not worth much.
“I knew my mum had some beautiful jewellery and furniture which was expensive when it was bought but actually is of little worth on the open market.
“I’ve decided to speak out now because I don’t want other people to make the same mistake I did. My mother loved her furniture and clothes but that doesn’t mean they were actually worth that much.
“Sorting out getting a tax rebate is just an extra hassle and stress which we don’t need at a time when we’re continuing to grieve.”


Expert warns families over inheritance tax valuations
Justine discovered the error after hiring valuation company Swift Values, which assessed dozens of photographs of her mum’s belongings.
The company warned that families can overestimate the value of inherited possessions, including furniture, jewellery and electrical items.
Founder Mark Littler said families were frequently caught out by using the wrong valuations when dealing with a loved one’s estate.
He said: “Far too many families are unknowingly giving money away to the taxman.
“We see this time and time again – families doing their best to be honest, only to end up overpaying because they’ve used replacement or insurance figures instead of probate values.
“It’s completely understandable – no one teaches you how to do this – but it means thousands of pounds that could have gone to loved ones ends up going to HMRC instead.”


































